54 Questions - Ideological Vaccination Step 1

Virus detection test v0.1

These questions do not try to be new. Most are normie - friendly.

They check what memes you carry and spread.


Doxometry = Doxa (belief ) + measurement

The empirical goal is to see what beliefs / tendencies make up 99.99% of human variance in beliefs.

This list is a prototype for that study, that is the list is not assumed complete. Later factor analysis might be done.

On none of these questions should there be unity of answer given a big enough sample.

If you find any of the questions new and thought - provoking, you’ve just been vaccinated. Vaccinated against being told about the topic by someone manipulative. Or against being surprised by a question on your stance on that.

The idea is that intellectually / philosophically mature person in 2021 has heard all of these questions in some format and has a certain stance on each (even if the stance is agnosticism).

Meaning

  1. Does human life have any meaning?

  2. Do you consider your life to have meaning?

  3. It is good to live without considering abstract ideas which are disagreed on or to find a deep belief in an idea / religion ?

Morality

  1. Do we have obligations towards our parents, although we did not ask to be born?

  2. Are people born good and spoiled by civilization?

  3. Origin of morality - is it an individual, culture / society, divine command theory , or maybe some independent form?

  4. Do objective morality and universal values exist?

  5. Euthanasia, abortion, suicide - what is your moral judgement on these issues?

  6. Is being a moral person conductive or essential to being a happy person?

Religion

  1. Perennialism - is it the case that all (or almost all) religions are in a certain sense right and their differences stem only from human imperfection?

  2. Existence of God - atheism, agnosticism, belief in an unspecified higher force, personal theism; what describes you most accurately?

  3. Nature of our knowledge of God - can we infer anything from the beauty of nature, of humans? Through direct prayers? Through sacred texts?

  4. God’s mode of existence - a person with human - like feelings or a cosmic force, or maybe something else?

  5. Do you believe in a punishment after death?

  6. Do you believe in a prize after death?

  7. Does in the present world exist a supernatural mechanism through which good deeds are rewarded in this life?

  8. Does in the present world exist a supernatural mechanism through which evil deeds are punished in this life?

  9. How often do you frequent any kind of temple / religious building for non-touristic purposes?

  10. Group participation - do you consider yourself an engaged member of your religious group?

  11. Ghosts, UFO - do the people who claim to have seen these phenomena have seen a real fragment of reality?

  12. Is science able to explain everything?

  13. Existence of magic - do you think that there is such a way of influencing reality?

  14. Do you possess an immaterial soul / energy? It is a medium for your consciousness?

  15. Have you tried any form of meditation?

  16. The problem of evil - does the existence of evil in the world exclude Existence of an all-powerful, all-benevolent god?

  17. Is Pascal’s wager valid?

  18. Soothsayers - what truth do they say about the future? Do they have access to a hidden knowledge?

  19. Do you have prophetic dreams?

  20. Do you believe that your religious allegiance group is always right?

  21. Miracles - have they been anytime, do they happen nowadays?

  22. Do we have free will in spite of the fact that decisions are to some extent foreseeable and taken in response to external factors?

  23. Would a massive loss of faith in free will bring demise to the society?

  24. Predestination - do you believe that each of us has a destiny, a role to fulfil? Is it avoidable? Or maybe rather it is a certain scenario (e.g. a duty), in which we will feel most fulfilled?

  25. Simulation hypothesis - do you think it is possible that we are living in a computer simulation? If so, what would be the consequences to your beliefs and practices?

The mind

  1. Mary’s room - did she get to know something new?

  2. Will there ever be an AI transcending all human capacities in real - world situations (not chess)?

  3. What constitutes a person's identity - body, memory, soul, social connections?

  4. Tabula rasa - are we born with any knowledge?

  5. Children - do they know something we do not? are they morally superior?

  6. What is the nature of consciousness? Something non-physical (e.g. a soul), biological brain, quantum consciousness?

  7. What makes a human?

Society

  1. Anarchism - does top - down organization bring harm to a person and would they be better off in a bottom - up organized community?

  2. Democracy - is it efficient, valid? - general evaluation

  3. Do democratic elections have meaning? - does my vote count?

  4. Evaluation of socialism - does it rest on wrong assumptions or just has been wrongly implemented or has been implemented right?

  5. Should humans voluntarily stop reproducing to go extinct and do not harm the Earth anymore?

  6. Will humanity colonize other planets?

  7. Will humanity survive another 100 years?

  8. Dream of immortality - would you use technological life extension technologies? Is humanity heading in the right direction with those technologies? A paradise found or a Pandora’s box?

  9. Do we have any special obligations towards our country of birth (other than those contractual legal ones stemming from living in any country, like paying taxes)?

  10. Nationalism - do you think that the best situation is when each state cares for its interests and independence or maybe it is worthwhile for countries to engage in international cooperation even at the price of some portion of their independence?

  11. LGBT rights - homosexual marriage, adoption, prosecuting homosexuality?

  12. Do you support the idea of a welfare state, understood as a practice of public healthcare, unemployment insurance?

  13. Intellectual property rights in the internet - should it be a place free from all intervention or should creators' rights be always expected?


That’s variant 0.1, let me know what questions should be added and which scrapped.

Variants iterate and each should have a higher coverage of human variance.

The optimal test, to which it should be asymptotically approaching, variant Omega is the one with least questions and highest coverage. There is an obvious tradeoff between length of the test and engagement, so that human measure is another factor on the number of questions.

Here is a list of topics that these questions were based on.

Are any topics missing? Maybe some topics would be better expressed with a different question than the ones that are above?

Maybe a different split of topics?

List of topics

The above list is not exhaustive, it just sketches a certain, non-final vision of their formulation in specific areas. These and other areas, which require a systematization of questions, are:

  • idealism, realism, dualism - ontology

  • knowledge - epistemology

  • free will and personal identity

  • political - type of regime, morality, economy

  • meaning of life

  • morality / ethics

  • a happy life

Metaphysics

  • time

  • being

  • objects and their properties

  • mind and body

  • cosmology

  • realism idealism

  • essence

  • universals

Epistemology

  • truth

  • scepticism, rationalism, empiricism, their progenitors

  • philosophy of the mind

  • philosophy of language

Axiology

  • the good

  • justice

  • ethics

  • good and evil

  • ethical and unethical behaviour

  • consequentialism, utilitarianism, deontology

Social philosophy

  • philosophy of politics

  • justice

  • law

  • property

  • citizen’s rights

  • citizen’s duties

  • how connects with ethics

Aesthetics

  • metaethics

  • aesthetics

  • beauty

  • art

  • taste

  • perception and creation

  • theory of art, literature, film, music

  • the beautiful

Philosophy of psychology

  • human nature

  • emotional reactions

Logics, semantics, mathematics

  • philosophy of science

  • logic

  • induction and deduction

  • philosophy of mathematics

  • game theory

Philosophy of religion

  • existence of God

  • faith and reason

  • religion and science

  • interpretation of religious experiences

  • questions about the possibility of an afterlife

  • the problem of religious language

  • existence of a soul

  • pluralism and religious diversity